Think aloud

This Indiana Pizzeria Is So Good That Even Dave Portnoy Ranked It Above Everything Else In Indy

Lilly Carter 11 min read
featured image 40877d48fb20 cfa62504b375
This Indiana Pizzeria Is So Good That Even Dave Portnoy Ranked It Above Everything Else In Indy

Some pizza places get famous slowly, one family dinner at a time. Others get a visit from the most famous pizza critic on the internet and suddenly the phones will not stop ringing.

A small shop north of Indianapolis landed in that second group when Dave Portnoy stopped by for one of his One Bite tests and handed it an 8.2, a score he does not give out lightly. Now people drive 40 minutes or more, order hours ahead, and still find it sold out some nights.

The place is tiny, the menu leans hard on New York style, and the owner has strong opinions about how a pie should be cooked. Keep reading to learn where it is, when it opens, what a large pie costs, and the planning tricks that help you actually get one.

A Slice of New York in Hamilton County

A Slice of New York in Hamilton County
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

The pizzeria everyone is buzzing about is called Brooklyn Char. It sits at 14765 Hazel Dell Crossing, Noblesville, IN 46062, in the growing Hamilton County suburbs just north of Indianapolis, Indiana, United States.

It is a pizza restaurant first and last. The whole point is New York style pies, the big, thin, foldable kind that East Coast transplants miss the moment they cross into the Midwest.

The location is easy to reach for folks across the north side of Indy. Locals mention it is simple to get to, which matters when you are racing home with a hot box on the passenger seat.

Do not expect a sprawling dining room or a fancy entrance. The shop is small and focused, built around the oven rather than the furniture.

That focus is exactly what put it on the map. A neighborhood spot in a quiet suburban shopping area became one of the most talked about pizza stops in central Indiana, and Hoosiers love a story like that.

So how did a modest storefront in Noblesville end up being called the best pie in the Indy area by so many people? The answer starts with one very famous bite.

The 8.2 That Changed Everything

The 8.2 That Changed Everything
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

Dave Portnoy has spent years tasting pizza on camera, and his One Bite scores carry real weight with pizza fans. When he stopped at Brooklyn Char, he gave it an 8.2.

Longtime fans of his videos know that number is a very high score. In the world of One Bite, anything above an 8 tends to send crowds running.

That is exactly what happened here. Plenty of people now arrive saying they came after the One Bite video, and the shop went from local favorite to road trip destination.

Some pizza lovers had the place on their list even before the famous visit. The Portnoy stamp simply poured fuel on a fire that was already going.

Of course, a big score also brings big expectations. Not every newcomer leaves agreeing with the judge, and some debate whether the hype fits their personal taste.

Still, many leave calling it the best pizza they have found in the Indy area, and some say it is the best they have had outside the East Coast. That kind of praise from former New Yorkers and New Jersey natives counts for a lot.

The score opened the door. What keeps people coming back is happening behind the counter.

Why Char Is in the Name

Why Char Is in the Name
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

A restaurant does not name itself Brooklyn Char by accident. The dark, blistered crust is the signature here, and it is very much on purpose.

Fans describe the crust as crispy, foldable, and cooked well done, with a semi thick edge that holds up to toppings. Many say the char is exactly what makes the pie stand out from chain delivery.

The owner has been clear about the philosophy. Some people like pizza doughy, and some like it well done, and this shop leans toward well done.

That style is not for everyone. A few diners find the edges too dark or the crust a bit tough, and occasionally a pie gets rotated onto a hotter stone than usual.

Here is the helpful part. The shop invites customers to say ahead of time if they want a lighter cook, and the same goes for the garlic knots.

So if you prefer a softer bake, ask for a light char when you order. If you want the full experience the name promises, just let the oven do its thing.

Either way, the crust is the conversation starter. The sauce, though, might be the quiet star.

Sauce, Cheese, and Hand Work

Sauce, Cheese, and Hand Work
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

Ask an East Coast transplant what matters most, and the answer is often the sauce. At this shop, the sauce gets some of the strongest praise of all.

It is described as light, bright, and not overly thick, with a classic East Coast style. One New Jersey native said it instantly took him back home, and some call it a little on the sweeter side.

The cheese gets serious attention too. Pies come topped with freshly grated cheeses, including fresh parm, and you can actually watch staff grating cheese and building pizzas.

That open view is part of the fun. Folks waiting for orders have spotted workers shredding cheese by hand and checking oven temperatures with infrared thermometers.

Even after garlic knots are finished, staff have been seen brushing on a little extra butter. Small touches like that tell you somebody cares about every box going out the door.

The dough is made from scratch, and the ingredients are described as fresh and high quality. Toppings are not skimpy either.

Not every bite wins every person over, and that is fine. But nobody watching the kitchen would call the effort lazy.

Garlic Knots Worth the Hype

Garlic Knots Worth the Hype
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

The pizza grabs the headlines, but the garlic knots might be the sneaky reason people return. They come up almost as often as the pies themselves.

Plenty of fans call them buttery, flavorful, and a must order side. Even a diner who was lukewarm on the pizza described the knots as phenomenal.

There is more on the side menu, too. Stuffed sticks and mozzarella stuffed bread show up on many orders, and both pair nicely with the house dipping sauces.

Speaking of sauces, you can order dipping options to go with your bread. A vodka sauce gets special love as a dipping partner, and the regular red sauce works well too.

Like the pizza, the knots are cooked with some color on them. If you prefer them softer, the shop has said you can simply ask for less cook.

A smart move for a group is to grab a pie plus a round of knots. That way everyone has something to snack on while the slices cool a bit on the ride home.

And if a side ends up being the highlight of your night, nobody is judging.

Specialty Pies With Playful Names

Specialty Pies With Playful Names
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

Some people walk in knowing they want plain pepperoni, and honestly, that is a popular pick. One self described boring pepperoni fan called it his favorite even after trying the fancier options.

Still, the menu has some fun names worth a look. Pies like the Charmander, the Bee Sting, and the Sweet Pig pop up in conversations about this place.

The Sweet Pig in particular splits opinions in a friendly way. Some people love it, while others say the combination just was not their style.

A tomato pie earns top marks from fans, and a vodka pie is another favorite starting point. Mushroom and onion and sausage pies also get regular mentions.

Double pepperoni, half and half orders, and extra cheese are all possible. That makes it easier to keep a whole family happy with a single box.

The specialty pies surprised more than a few people who came in expecting basic slices. Many say they plan to rotate through the whole menu over time.

That might be the best strategy here. Start with a classic, then come back and get a little adventurous.

Small Room, Big Crowds

Small Room, Big Crowds
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

Space is the one thing this shop does not have in large supply. The store is small, with only a handful of seats inside and a bit of seating outdoors.

It is set up mainly as an order and pickup place. Most people grab their boxes and head home, though you can absolutely eat there if you like.

The vibe is relaxed, both inside and out. Some describe the atmosphere as cute and chill, which suits a casual weeknight pizza run.

Weekends can get busy, especially in the afternoon. The small room fills up fast for the number of people coming through.

A handy tip from locals is to split up if you are with someone. One person orders while the other claims a seat.

Families with kids tend to do best with takeout, especially on a Saturday. Couples or solo diners might enjoy grabbing a table and watching the kitchen in action.

The staff gets plenty of credit, too. Workers are described as friendly, welcoming, and hard working, even when the line stretches out.

Just do not expect to linger for hours on a packed night. This room was built for pizza, not parties.

The Order Ahead Game Plan

The Order Ahead Game Plan
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

Here is the most important advice in this whole article. Order ahead, and order early.

Brooklyn Char opens at 3 PM on weekdays it operates, and some nights it has been sold out before 6. One fan suggested going online right at 3 PM to lock in a spot.

Lead times can stretch, especially on weekends. People have run into waits of three hours on a Saturday night and around four hours on a Friday.

On quieter afternoons, things move faster. Walk in orders have taken about 20 minutes to come out of the oven.

Some first timers have even been turned away on a Wednesday night because the shop had already sold out. Many took it as a sign of a busy small business and came back better prepared.

You can order online or call the shop for pickup. If you have any requests, like a lighter bake or a specific topping change, mention it when you order.

Planning ahead turns a long wait into an easy pickup. A little homework now saves a lot of hungry pacing later.

Hours, Costs, and Payment Tips

Hours, Costs, and Payment Tips
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

Timing your trip matters, because this shop keeps a short week. It is closed on Monday and Tuesday.

From Wednesday through Friday, it runs from 3 PM to 9 PM. Saturday hours are noon to 9 PM, and Sunday is noon to 8 PM.

Now for the numbers. A large pie measures 18 inches, and a cheese pizza runs about $26 before extras.

Extra cheese adds about $2. Several people paid somewhere between $30 and $33 out the door for a large, depending on toppings and tax.

Some say the price is a bit high, while others shrug and point out that everything costs more these days. An 18 inch pie can easily feed a family or leave leftovers for the weekend.

One practical note worth knowing before you go. The shop does not keep a cash drawer for staff safety, so bring a debit or credit card to avoid any surprises.

With the hours, the price, and the payment sorted, you are ready. Now comes the fun part, deciding if the drive is worth it for you.

Worth the Drive to Noblesville?

Worth the Drive to Noblesville?
© Brooklyn Char, Noblesville, IN

Every famous pizza place has its fans and its doubters, and this one is no different. Still, the shop holds a 4.4 star standing across more than 300 opinions, which says a lot.

Fans of true New York style pies tend to be the happiest. Those who love a crispy, charred, foldable slice often call it the best around Indy or even all of Hamilton County.

If you prefer soft, doughy pizza, you have options. Just ask for a lighter cook when you order and the kitchen will adjust.

The owner is invested and outspoken, and the staff clearly takes the craft seriously. That passion shows up in the hand grated cheese and the careful oven checks.

For road trippers, the formula is simple. Pick a Wednesday through Sunday, order the moment ordering opens, and bring a card.

Grab a pie, add some garlic knots, and maybe try a specialty with a playful name. Then decide for yourself whether Portnoy got it right.

Either way, you will have a story to tell. And in Indiana, a good pizza story is something worth sharing with the whole family.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *