Clare sits right in the middle of the mitten, and plenty of Michiganders roll past it on the way up north without a second thought. That is a mistake worth fixing.
Tucked downtown is a bakery that hand-makes Amish pies from scratch, fills a long glass case with doughnuts, and sells an elephant ear for about three dollars. The twist is who runs it, and the story behind that is half the fun.
The shop opens at 5 AM every single day, so early birds and road-trippers both get a fair shot. Clare also happens to sit in Michigan Amish country, which explains why the pie shelf here feels more like a trip to Indiana than a stop off US-127.
Keep reading for the address, the must-try items, a few honest tips, and what a family can expect to spend.
A Downtown Clare Bakery With a Badge

Some of the best Michigan detours start with a billboard and a hunch. This one ends at 521 N McEwan St, Clare, MI 48617, in the heart of downtown Clare.
The shop is Cops & Doughnuts – Clare City Bakery, and the name is not a gimmick. The bakery is owned by police officers, and that theme runs through the whole building.
Clare is the headquarters location for the Cops & Doughnuts shops found around the state. Other branches exist, but this is the original spot that fans call the one worth the special trip.
The building spreads across three storefronts. That gives it far more room than a typical corner doughnut counter.
Inside, the layout splits into three parts. A gift shop comes first, the bakery cases sit in the middle, and a seating room waits at the back.
Clare itself sits in the center of the Lower Peninsula along the route many families take when heading north. That makes it an easy stop for anyone already on the road.
Parking is usually simple. Spots in front fill up, but public lots sit around downtown within a short walk.
The address is the easy part, and the harder part is choosing what to order.
Officers Behind the Counter

Retired police officers running a doughnut shop sounds like the setup to a joke. In Clare, it is simply how the business works.
The bakery is officer-owned, and guests sometimes get the chance to meet one of the owners in person. A retired officer known as Bubba has a reputation for sharing stories that brighten a family’s visit.
That personal touch matters to a lot of Michiganders. Many stop in partly to support local police officers while picking up a box of treats.
The dining area doubles as a small display of the theme. Patches from police departments across the country, plus some from Canada, cover the space.
Neat artifacts fill the room as well, giving people something to browse while they eat. A couple of photo spots are set up for anyone who wants a keepsake picture.
The shop calls itself historic, and its fame has grown across Michigan over the years. Some fans admit they waited years before finally making the drive.
Grandparents bring grandkids at different ages, and the stop becomes a family tradition. Kids tend to remember this one long after the car ride home.
The jokes write themselves, but the hospitality here is no laughing matter.
Amish Pies From Scratch

Shipshewana gets the headlines for Amish baking, but Clare sits in the middle of Michigan Amish country too. The bakery leans into that heritage with its own Amish pies.
These pies are handmade from scratch with simple ingredients. The fillings are made in the shop as well, and everything is baked on site.
That sets them apart from wrapped snack pies sold at gas stations and supermarkets. Fans of the bakery point to the apple and cherry versions as the standouts.
Cherry pie earns steady praise, which makes sense in a state so proud of its cherries. A cherry fritter also shows up on many favorite lists.
Pineapple upside down cake is another homestyle option that regulars mention. It fits right in with the old-fashioned feel of the pie shelf.
For budget-minded families, a hand pie or two makes an easy add-on to a doughnut order. It is a small purchase that feels like a proper treat.
Selection can change from day to day, so it helps to arrive with a backup choice in mind.
Shipshewana may be a long drive south, but this slice of Amish tradition is right off the highway.
The Doughnut Case Lineup

Doughnuts are in the name, so the case had better deliver. It does, with a huge variety and sizes on the large side.
Long johns are among the most talked-about items. Custard-filled doughnuts are often packed heavy with filling.
The maple bar topped with bacon is the famous oddball. Some love the sweet and salty mix, while others call it a fun one-time try.
A maple bacon cinnamon roll, nicknamed a cousin Vinny, has its own fan club. Cinnamon twists and strawberry bismarks also earn plenty of praise.
Flavors go well past glazed. Banana cream with chocolate topping, peanut butter cream, and triple chocolate all appear in the lineup.
Honesty helps here too. A few people have found some cream-filled doughnuts lighter on filling than expected, so results can vary.
The cannolis use a mascarpone filling rather than the typical ricotta. That is worth knowing before ordering.
A day-old case offers older doughnuts at a lower cost. Ask which case you are buying from if freshness matters most.
With this many choices, a mixed half dozen is the smartest strategy.
More Than Doughnuts on the Shelves

Not everyone in the car wants a doughnut, and that is fine. The Clare shop bakes a wide spread of other treats.
Cookies are one of the most mentioned items, from large chocolate chip to no-bake cookies. Brownies and marshmallow rice squares are big hits with kids.
Cinnamon rolls come by the box, and many fans rank them as the best thing in the building. Sticky buns with pecans keep some travelers coming back year after year.
Muffins, cream horns, strudels, and turnovers fill out the shelves. Cakes and cupcakes round out the options.
The elephant ear is a quiet bargain. It runs about $2.99, far less than the six to eight dollars common at a carnival.
Drinks keep things simple. Coffee, hot chocolate, and pop are all available.
The coffee gets regular praise for being hot and fresh. It pairs well with a sweet for anyone needing a road break.
Some treats carry a lot of icing, so folks who prefer less sugar may want to lean toward rolls or pies.
Variety like this keeps everybody in the family happy.
Souvenirs Worth a Second Look

A doughnut lasts about five minutes. A funny T-shirt from the gift shop can last years.
The first room inside is a full souvenir shop. Shelves hold shirts, hoodies, mugs, tumblers, magnets, and plush doughnuts.
The T-shirts lean into the cop theme with plenty of humor. Many people walk in planning to buy pastries and leave with a shirt as well.
Quality on the merchandise is solid, and prices stay reasonable. It makes for a handy stop to grab a gift for someone back home.
Jams and jerky are also for sale. Those travel well for anyone heading on to a cabin or campground.
Some call the gift room touristy, and that is fair. Still, browsing costs nothing, and kids enjoy looking around while adults wait in line.
Budget-minded families can set a small spending limit before going in. The shirts have a way of finding their way into shopping bags.
The gift shop turns a quick snack stop into a small Michigan keepsake.
Who Feels Right at Home Here

Grandparents with sticky-fingered grandkids, road-tripping couples, and coffee regulars all share the tables here. The crowd is a true slice of Michigan.
The seating room gives people space to slow down. Indoor seating is plentiful, and outdoor seating is available as well.
Downtown charm adds to the appeal. It feels like a small-town hangout rather than a chain stop.
Regulars sometimes chat with whoever walks in. Most enjoy it, though quieter guests may want a corner table.
Staff are widely described as friendly, patient, and helpful. Even on busy days, plenty of workers keep the line moving.
Like any busy shop, an off moment can happen at the counter. Most people still leave with good things to say about the team.
Restrooms are kept clean and tidy. That matters when a family has been driving for hours.
Former locals who moved out of state make a point to stop by when visiting relatives. That kind of loyalty says plenty.
Families with kids, retirees on a day trip, and anyone supporting local police will fit right in.
Hours, Costs, and a Friendly Verdict

Early risers win here. The bakery opens at 5 AM every day of the week.
Closing time is 7 PM Sunday through Thursday. On Friday and Saturday, the doors stay open until 8 PM.
Prices stay friendly for families. A strawberry bismark runs about $2, a cinnamon twist about $2.29, a large cookie about $2, and a box of cinnamon rolls about $8.49.
One couple ordered six doughnuts and two cannolis for around $20 with tip. Prices may vary, so check the board when ordering.
Busy periods can bring a line, especially on holiday weekends. Arriving earlier in the day gives the best pick of the case.
Remember the day-old case if fresh-baked matters most. It is a deal, but it is a different shelf.
Is it worth the drive? For Michiganders heading north, the answer leans yes.
Not every doughnut will change your life, and the custard has its critics. Still, the Amish pies, cinnamon rolls, and officer-owned charm make this a stop worth adding to the map.
Bring a few dollars and an appetite, and Clare will handle the rest.