Think aloud

This Indiana Eatery Went Completely Gluten-Free And Still Piles On Comfort Food Worth The Drive

Lilly Carter 11 min read
featured image 0545bb8e80b5 11a99307ac49
This Indiana Eatery Went Completely Gluten-Free And Still Piles On Comfort Food Worth The Drive

Some people drive an hour and a half for a single breakfast sandwich, and they plan to do it again. In historic downtown Franklin, a small cafe on the courthouse square has quietly turned into a road-trip destination for families dealing with celiac disease and gluten sensitivity.

Every item on the menu is gluten-free, yet the plates lean hard into comfort: biscuits and gravy, quiche, hearty sandwiches and thick brownies. Friends who eat gluten come along too, and plenty of them say they cannot tell the difference.

Regulars make monthly trips from out of town just to eat somewhere they know is safe. Keep reading to learn where it is, what to order, when to go, and what to expect before you plan your own drive.

A Courthouse Square Address Worth Knowing

A Courthouse Square Address Worth Knowing
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Johnson County’s courthouse square holds a cafe that has changed weekend plans for a lot of Hoosiers. Its name is 1823 Bakehouse, and it sits at 25 E Court St Ste A, Franklin, IN 46131, in the United States.

Franklin is a short drive south of Indianapolis. The historic downtown is the kind of place where storefronts line the streets and the courthouse anchors everything around it.

The Bakehouse fits right into that setting. It operates as a cafe and bakery, serving breakfast, lunch, coffee, tea and a steady case of baked goods.

Here is the twist that makes people put it on their maps. The whole operation is gluten-free, so nobody has to quiz the counter about which items are safe.

For the many guests with celiac disease, that one fact changes the meal entirely. Instead of scanning a menu for the two or three safe choices, they get to pick anything they want.

The location is easy to find, tucked into a cozy nook near the square. Nearby shops and restaurants surround it, which makes a visit feel like part of a bigger afternoon out.

Finding the front door is the easy part. Choosing what to order turns out to be the real challenge.

Eight Years of Flour Made In-House

Eight Years of Flour Made In-House
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Gluten-free baking has a reputation problem, and this kitchen has spent years working against it. The Bakehouse has been open for about eight years, according to the owners.

One detail sets the operation apart. The team makes its pastries and its bread from scratch using a flour blend of its own.

That matters more than it might seem. Store-bought gluten-free bread tends to be small and crumbly, and the owners point out that their loaves are some of the biggest gluten-free bread served in restaurants.

They are also honest about the limits. Gluten-free bread simply does not rise the way wheat bread does, and no recipe changes that basic fact.

The house-made approach shows up across the menu. Sandwich bread holds together under fillings, which is a rare win in the gluten-free world.

Guests with other allergies notice the care, too. Some describe the cafe as free of almost all allergens, though dairy-free choices on a given day may be limited to a couple of baked items.

The owner, Heather, and her team are frequently singled out for being genuine and welcoming. That personal touch helps explain why a small storefront has built such loyal followers across Indiana.

Scratch baking takes time. Around here, it also earns repeat customers.

Biscuits, Gravy and Other Breakfast Comebacks

Biscuits, Gravy and Other Breakfast Comebacks
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Three years without a breakfast biscuit is a long time. One guest who hit that milestone called the biscuit sandwich here the best breakfast sandwich ever, then promised to make the hour and a half drive often.

Biscuits and gravy are one of the most talked-about plates in the building. The gravy earns steady praise, and the dish shows up on order after order.

Opinions on the biscuits themselves vary a little. A few people find them slightly dry or sweet, while most simply clean the plate and plan the next trip.

Quiche is another morning favorite, including a ham version. It is a popular grab for anyone heading out the door with breakfast to go.

Cinnamon rolls also appear on plenty of trays. Together, these dishes make the case that gluten-free does not have to mean giving up classic Midwest breakfast.

The cafe opens at 9 AM on the days it operates. That gives early birds a solid shot at the morning lineup before the lunch crowd arrives.

For celiac families, a plate of biscuits and gravy can feel like a small reunion. Sometimes comfort food is less about the recipe and more about finally being allowed to order it.

The Cuban That Steals the Show

The Cuban That Steals the Show
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Ask around about the lunch menu and one sandwich keeps coming up. The Cuban has become something of a signature, and even the owners have cheered that you cannot beat it.

Its success comes down to the bread. House-made gluten-free bread holds up well under hearty fillings, which does not happen often with gluten-free sandwiches.

There is also a blonde Cuban sandwich on the menu. Fans have called it the best Cuban they have had anywhere in Indiana, gluten-free or not.

Other sandwiches get love, too. A turkey spinach sandwich arrives with a generous amount of food and homemade chips on the side.

The ultimate grilled cheese is another comfort pick. The kitchen uses real cheddar rather than American cheese.

Beyond sandwiches, the menu branches out into chicken tacos, vegetarian tacos and a white chicken chili. Sandwiches tend to be the safest bet for portion size, with chips included.

Not every plate lands perfectly for everyone. A few guests have found certain vegetarian items heavy on salt or cheese, so first-timers may want to start with the sandwiches that have built the reputation.

A good Cuban is a balancing act. This one manages it on bread that has no wheat at all.

Brownies, Cookies and Pocket-Sized Pies

Brownies, Cookies and Pocket-Sized Pies
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Dessert might be the main reason some people come at all. The bakery case is stocked with brownies, chocolate chip cookies, cinnamon rolls and more.

The brownie earns the loudest praise. Even guests who eat gluten have called it one of the best brownies they have had in a while.

A German chocolate brownie also has its own fan club. The brownies are popular enough that they are sold through Crowe and Clover in addition to the cafe.

Then there are the sugar cream pies. Indiana’s state pie comes in individual sizes here, which makes it easy for gluten-free family members to have their own.

Fun fact for road-trippers: sugar cream pie is often called Hoosier pie. Finding a safe gluten-free version is a small victory for many Indiana families.

Many guests note the treats are not overly sweet, which is unusual for gluten-free products. A cake-style donut sometimes shows up, topped with sweet icing.

Not every item hits for every guest. Banana bread has drawn mixed opinions, so the brownies remain the safer opening move.

Plenty of people buy extras for the drive home. Considering how far some of them travel, that seems like smart planning.

Lattes With a Playful Streak

Lattes With a Playful Streak
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Coffee here goes well beyond a plain cup of drip. The drink menu covers hot, cold and iced options with a sense of fun.

A butter beer latte and butter beer frappe are among the playful picks. A berry bliss latte and a s’mores latte have also appeared on the lineup.

Chai, teas and smoothies round things out. Strawberry and blueberry smoothies get compliments, with the blueberry noted for not being overly sweet.

Results can vary by drink and by day. Some guests rave about the specialty lattes, while others find a particular one just fine.

For drinks enjoyed in the cafe, cups are paper. That is worth knowing for anyone hoping for a mug to linger over.

Many locals call it their favorite coffee shop in historic downtown Franklin. It works as a quick stop on a walk around the square or as a longer break with a book.

Pairing a seasonal latte with a brownie is a popular move. A smoothie alongside a Cuban sandwich makes a fine lunch combo, too.

The menu changes the coffee break from routine to small outing. That might be the best kind of upgrade.

Small Room, Big Small-Town Vibe

Small Room, Big Small-Town Vibe
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Space is limited, and that is part of the charm. The cafe is a cozy, small room, so finding a seat during a rush can take patience.

When it is calm, though, the room invites people to stay. Guests bring books or journals and settle in for an afternoon.

Shelves hold handmade goods and local art for sale. Browsing them is an easy way to pass the time while an order is prepared.

A printer is available, which is a handy bonus for travelers. Music is usually playing, and on some days it runs on the loud side.

The staff is often described as friendly and welcoming, and especially helpful with allergy questions. A few people have had less warm moments at the counter, as happens at any busy spot.

Families with mixed diets fit right in. A gluten-free spouse and a non-gluten-free partner can share a table and both order freely.

Wedding couples have also turned to the bakery for gluten-free cakes and cupcakes. Guests at those events reportedly could not tell the cake was gluten-free.

It is the kind of room that rewards slowing down. Just maybe not at noon on a Saturday.

Kuji Alley and a Stroll Around the Square

Kuji Alley and a Stroll Around the Square
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Right next door, an alley does something alleys rarely do. It gets people to stop and look.

Kuji Alley sits beside the Bakehouse. It was designed and fabricated by local artist Matt LaFary, owner of Expo Arts, LLC.

That makes it an easy add-on for anyone grabbing a coffee. A short walk turns a snack stop into a small art outing.

Downtown Franklin itself is fun to explore on foot. Shops and restaurants surround the courthouse square, and the town has a quiet, step-back-in-time feel.

Parking is described as easy, which matters for road-trippers. Arriving, eating and wandering the square can all happen without much fuss.

Families can build a whole afternoon here. Breakfast at the cafe, a loop around the shops, a look at the alley art and a pastry for the ride home make a tidy plan.

Retirees and day-trippers from Indianapolis will find the pace relaxed. Nothing here demands a rush.

Small towns often hide their best moments in side streets. In Franklin, one of them sits right beside the bakery door.

Hours, Costs and Crowd Timing

Hours, Costs and Crowd Timing
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Planning ahead pays off with a place this popular. The cafe opens at 9 AM Tuesday through Saturday and closes at 6 PM on those days.

Sunday hours run from 9 AM to 4 PM. Monday is the day off, so skip that one when mapping a trip.

Costs run higher than a typical diner. Gluten-free ingredients are pricey, and the menu reflects it.

Some real examples help set expectations. A slice of quiche has been priced around $13, sandwiches can run over $10, and two small slices of banana bread have cost about $5.

Lines can build on busy days. The room is small, so waiting to order may mean standing close to tables.

Arriving near opening or in the mid-afternoon on weekdays is a reasonable way to dodge the crush. Ordering baked goods to go is another option when seats are full.

The cafe also handles catering, including wedding cakes and cupcakes. Celiac couples planning big events have found it a solid choice.

A little timing goes a long way here. So does arriving hungry.

Why the Miles Make Sense

Why the Miles Make Sense
© 1823 Bakehouse, Franklin, IN

Some friends drive 30 minutes out of their way every month for one reason. Their companion with celiac disease can eat anything on the menu without worry.

That kind of trust is hard to earn. This little cafe has built it over about eight years with scratch baking and a fully gluten-free kitchen.

The comfort food holds up its end of the deal. Biscuits and gravy, the Cuban, quiche and brownies give people a reason to come back, whether they need gluten-free or not.

It is not a perfect spot for everyone. Seating is tight, prices run high and busy hours can mean a wait.

Still, the overall picture is strong. The cafe holds a 4.6-star average across 242 Google ratings, a solid sign of steady satisfaction.

For Indiana families, it offers something simple but meaningful. Everyone at the table gets to order freely.

Pair it with a walk around the square and a peek at Kuji Alley. Then grab a box of brownies for the drive home.

Comfort food is supposed to bring people together. Here, it finally brings everyone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *