One of Texas’ Best Ice Cream Sundaes Is Hiding in This Nostalgic Small-Town Scoop Shop
Tucked onto Denton’s historic square, Beth Marie’s Old Fashioned Ice Cream feels like stepping into a sweet, time traveling daydream. The waffle cone aroma hits first, then the glow of the antique soda fountain sets the pace for slow, happy bites. Locals swear the sundaes rank with Texas’ best, and after one spoonful of hot fudge, it is hard to disagree.
Come early, bring friends, and prepare to argue lovingly over which flavor wins the night.
1. The Legendary Hot Fudge Sundae
If you are here for one thing, make it the hot fudge sundae. Vanilla scoops arrive snow-cold and sturdy, built to shoulder ribbons of molten chocolate that perfume the whole table. The whipped cream sits tall, crowned with a cherry, while toasted pecans add a buttery crunch.
You will want to move fast, then slow down. The fudge slips into every edge of the bowl and turns each bite into a warm-cold contrast that feels unreasonably satisfying. Napkins will stack, conversation will pause, and suddenly Denton’s square just hums outside.
This sundae is simple on purpose, a reminder that classics do not need tricks. Bring someone you like sharing with, or pretend you did.
2. Baa Baa Blackberry Scoop
Blackberry lovers, this flavor leans juicy and bright with a creamy finish that keeps it from turning tart. You can see tiny fruit freckles, and that first lick tastes like summer evenings on the square. Order it in a fresh waffle cone for a warm vanilla hug beneath the berry.
It is the kind of scoop that makes you slow-walk around the courthouse lawn. Every bite lingers, gently sweet, then floral as it melts. If you enjoy pairing, add a companion scoop like lemon drop to nudge the fruit higher.
Ask for a taste before you commit, but truthfully you will know immediately. It paints your tongue purple and your mood brighter. You will not regret it.
3. Texas Honey Whiskey Indulgence
This one whispers Texas with every creamy spoonful. The honey arrives first, smooth and floral, then the whiskey warmth follows like a soft curtain closing. It is grown-up without being gruff, a perfect date night scoop after dinner on the square.
You will taste balance here, not a boozy punch. Pair it with butter pecan or vanilla bean if you want to spotlight the honey’s glow. The texture is plush, almost custard-like, leaving a silky finish that begs another bite.
If you are experimenting, ask for a sample, then order confidently. It fits beautifully in a sundae with caramel and salted nuts. Sit near the front window and watch the night drift by Denton-style.
4. Waffle Cones Baked In-House
The smell of fresh waffle cones is Beth Marie’s unofficial greeting. That buttery-sugar scent trails you from the door to the case, daring you to skip a cup. Cones here are thick, golden, and supportive, the kind you can trust with towering scoops.
You will hear the soft snap when you bite, then the warm vanilla note lands. It turns a good scoop into a great handheld moment. If you like a crisp edge, ask for the freshest batch, rolled minutes before.
They hold up late into the evening hours, which helps when lines run long. Grab napkins anyway. A perfect cone drip is part of the ritual, especially on a Denton summer night.
5. Banana Split On The Square
There is joy in the ceremony of a banana split, and Beth Marie’s keeps it playful and classic. Three scoops, sauces drizzled just messy enough, and bananas tucked like smiles along the sides. Whipped cream mountains and cherries finish the look.
You will want to rotate the dish, finding your favorite spoon angle. The pineapple bite, the strawberry swirl, the fudge melting into vanilla, it all lands like a throwback celebration. Shareable, yes, but you might guard the best corner.
Ask for flavor suggestions if you freeze at the board. Staff will steer you to combos that sing. Then head outside, sit on a bench, and let the square soundtrack your split.
6. Late-Night Scoops And Friendly Lines
Lines can stretch late, especially on weekends, but they move with purpose. You will watch indecisive stares turn into grins as samples settle arguments. The vibe stays warm and lively, a small-town soundtrack of laughter and clinking spoons.
Hours run deep into the night most days, so dessert after a concert or dinner works perfectly. If a team member seems rushed, give grace and patience. They are juggling cones, blenders, and your best flavor decision under bright lights.
Price-wise, it is a treat destination, not a bargain bin. The tradeoff is quality and the Denton-square experience. Step out with your cup, and the courthouse glow makes every scoop feel cinematic.
7. Nut-Allergy Care And Clean Scoops
If you navigate nut allergies, you will appreciate the careful approach here. Staff can pull from a separate area and use fresh scoops on request. They will not guarantee zero crossover, but the attention to detail feels reassuring and kind.
Speak up when you order. You will see gloves change and scoops swapped, which makes the experience less stressful. Try safe-leaning flavors like classic chocolate or berry-forward choices and enjoy the peace of mind.
Grab a table near the window, breathe, and celebrate dessert without worry taking over. The team’s patience helps, even when lines are long. You deserve to savor something sweet, and this place meets you halfway with care.
8. Sundaes, Shakes, And Old-Soul Vibes
Beth Marie’s is more than scoops, it is an atmosphere you feel in your shoulders relaxing. Retro mirrors, shiny fountain fixtures, and a chalkboard of 100-plus flavors set the mood. Order a shake thick enough to challenge a straw, or a sundae dressed to impress.
You can bring kids, out-of-town friends, or a first date and score smiles either way. The staff moves quickly, and the seating invites lingering. It is the kind of place that turns a quick stop into a small celebration.
Check the hours, especially opening times on weekdays, then stroll the square after. Denton’s heartbeat pairs perfectly with ice cream spoons clinking. You will leave already planning your next flavor lineup.
