Think aloud

This Is The Amish Market In Michigan Where Locals Drive Out For Handmade Goods You Won’t Find Anywhere Else

Hannah Whitmore 14 min read
featured image ffcb0b5b383a 4c1559faf1b8
This Is The Amish Market In Michigan Where Locals Drive Out For Handmade Goods You Won't Find Anywhere Else

Some of the best stops in Michigan sit just off the highway, easy to miss unless someone tells you about them. Near the small village of Tustin in Osceola County, there is an Amish store that Michiganders plan their road trips around.

People pull off the highway for sandwiches built on bread baked right there, and they leave with cookies, flour, and sometimes a piece of handmade furniture. Cash is king here, so plan ahead.

Families heading north, retirees cruising between Grand Rapids and Traverse City, and locals stocking their pantries all end up in the same checkout line. Keep reading to learn where it is, what to grab, which day brings a special treat, and the one thing you should never forget to bring along.

A Country Store Just Off the Highway

A Country Store Just Off the Highway
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Some road trip stops earn their spot on the map one sandwich at a time. Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture sits at 20030 200th Ave, Tustin, MI 49688, in the rural heart of northern Lower Michigan.

The store is an Amish bulk food market with a deli, a bakery, and a separate side devoted to furniture and home goods. It is listed as a grocery store, but that label barely covers what fills the shelves.

Getting there is simple. The store sits roughly a two minute drive off the highway, which makes it an easy detour for anyone traveling on M-115.

That convenience matters to Michigan drivers watching gas and time. A quick exit, a short drive, and you are parked in front of a store that feels far removed from the big box chains.

The parking lot is dirt, so expect a true country setting rather than a paved plaza. Inside, the space is compact, clean, and packed with goods.

Shoppers give the place a strong 4.7 star standing across more than 340 opinions, which says plenty about how often people come back. Not bad for a little store tucked among the fields.

Now that you know where to find it, the next question is what makes people keep returning.

The Sandwich Everyone Talks About

The Sandwich Everyone Talks About
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Ask around about this store and the first word you will hear is sandwich. It is the single most talked about item, and for good reason.

The sandwiches are made to order on bread baked in house. That fresh bread is the foundation, and fans say it is what sets these apart from anything at a gas station counter.

The daily special can be large enough for two people to split and still walk away satisfied. That kind of portion is welcome news for families trying to stretch a lunch budget.

Some regulars mention that sizes can vary from visit to visit. Sometimes the fillings are piled high, and other times they are more modest.

Even so, the praise keeps flowing. Many call it one of the best sandwiches they have ever had, and plenty of travelers stop specifically to grab one for lunch or dinner on the road.

Speed is another plus. The deli has a reputation for turning orders around quickly, sometimes in just a few minutes.

Lunch meat lovers have options, but so do vegetarians. That leads to a fun little detail about how ordering actually works.

How the Deli Slip System Works

How the Deli Slip System Works
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

No touchscreen kiosk here. Ordering at the deli is refreshingly old school.

Customers fill out a paper slip next to the deli case to build their sandwich. You pick your bread, meats, cheeses, and toppings, then hand it over.

The bread choices go beyond plain white. One standout option is jalapeno bread, which pairs well with a fully loaded vegetarian sandwich.

That vegetarian sandwich on jalapeno bread has come in at around $7.50. Years ago, sandwiches ran closer to $5, so prices have climbed, and they may vary today.

Still, for a fresh made sandwich on homemade bread, many Michiganders consider it a fair deal. Several shoppers describe the sandwiches as affordable, especially given the size.

The slip system also keeps things moving during busy stretches. Once your slip is in, you can browse the aisles while the deli crew gets to work.

Just be aware that wait times may run longer on busy days. A little patience pays off when your name gets called and lunch is ready.

Bread Baked Right Under the Roof

Bread Baked Right Under the Roof
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Fresh bread is the quiet hero of this whole operation. The same loaves that hold the sandwiches together are also sold by the loaf.

Store made bread shows up again and again as a reason people stop. Some shoppers come just for a loaf or two to take home for the week.

Having a bakery in the same building as the deli means the bread never travels far. It goes from the oven to the shelf or straight into a sandwich.

That setup is part of the appeal for families who want simple, homestyle food. It feels a bit like grabbing bread from a neighbor who happens to bake a lot of it.

The bakery case holds more than bread, too. Pies, cookies, and other treats line the shelves alongside the loaves.

For anyone keeping an eye on ingredients, a heads up is useful. Many bakery items contain soy or vegetable oils, so check labels if that matters to your household.

Bread may be the foundation, but the sweets are what send many shoppers home with an extra bag.

Cookies With a Cult Following

Cookies With a Cult Following
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

A cookie becoming the reason for a road trip sounds unlikely. Then again, most cookies are not the buttery raisin cookies sold here.

These little treats have earned a loyal fan base. Some describe them as tasting like butter cake, and others have called them the best cookie they have ever had.

Word of mouth spreads fast with these. People hear about them online, try a package, and promptly become repeat buyers.

The molasses cookie gets its own share of praise. Some shoppers who came for a sandwich ended up talking more about the molasses cookie afterward.

Homemade cookies come packaged, and a pack of six has been priced at about $6.50. Prices may vary, and some find that a bit steep compared to grocery store cookies.

Others consider it a fair trade for something baked by hand. It comes down to whether you are looking for a bargain or a treat worth the stop.

Tip for first timers: grab a pack for the car and another for home. They tend to disappear before the next exit.

Tuesday Means Hand Pie Day

Tuesday Means Hand Pie Day
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Mark your calendar, because one weekday carries a special reputation. Tuesdays are known as little hand pie day.

Fried pies and hand pies are a popular bakery item here. Regulars passing through on a Tuesday make a point of stopping to grab some.

These small pies are easy to eat on the go. That makes them a natural fit for a road trip snack that does not need a fork or a plate.

Donuts also appear among the bakery offerings. Between donuts, hand pies, and cookies, the sweet side of the store gives sandwiches some real competition.

Full size pies are available too. Some shoppers pick up a whole pie alongside their sandwich order to take home for dessert.

If your travel schedule is flexible, a Tuesday visit gives you the best shot at the hand pie lineup. Just remember the store is closed on Thursdays and Sundays, so plan the rest of your week accordingly.

A Tuesday detour might just become a new family tradition.

Fifty Pound Bags and Bulk Bins

Fifty Pound Bags and Bulk Bins
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Serious bakers, this is your aisle. The bulk food section is a big part of why locals stock up here regularly.

Shelves carry 50 pound bags of flour, plus oatmeal and organic oatmeal. For households that bake often, buying in bulk can make a lot of sense.

Baking ingredients are a strong suit. Flours, grains, and other supplies fill the shelves for anyone who makes bread, pies, or cookies at home.

The spice and seasoning selection also stands out. Some regulars say they can always find what they need here, which is high praise for a small store.

Snacks and candies are mixed in with the bulk goods. Plenty of shoppers leave with a bag of something sweet next to their flour.

Soup mixes and homemade jams round out the pantry options. These make easy gifts or simple additions to a weeknight meal.

On price, opinions differ. Some find good value, while others notice certain items cost the same or more than nearby stores, so compare if you are budget shopping.

Coolers Full of Country Staples

Coolers Full of Country Staples
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Beyond the dry goods, the coolers hold plenty worth a look. Refrigerated items include meats, dairy products, and soda pop.

Local bacon is one of the finds here. Shoppers who have tried it say they would buy it again.

The store also offers 100 percent grass fed milk. It is the kind of item that draws people who prefer simpler, farm style groceries.

Fresh cheese makes an appearance as well. The deli counter offers meats and cheeses at prices many describe as affordable.

Produce has also been part of the mix. Selection may change, so it is best to see what is in stock when you arrive.

Meat deal hunters should set expectations. The freezer section is smaller than at some other Amish stores, so it may not be the place for big freezer hauls.

Still, a few staples from the cooler pair nicely with a fresh loaf and a sandwich for the road. Bring a cooler bag if you have a long drive ahead.

The Furniture Side of the Story

The Furniture Side of the Story
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Plenty of shoppers walk in for lunch and never realize there is a whole other side to the building. That second side is dedicated to furniture.

Handmade furniture and other home furnishings fill the space. The look leans rustic, which suits anyone who loves a cozy, country style home.

Handcrafted items go beyond larger pieces. Smaller home goods also appear, offering options for those who are not shopping for a dining table.

Some longtime fans have described the furniture as amazing. It adds a whole new reason to stop, even for people who already ate lunch on the road.

Because the furniture shares a roof with the grocery and deli, a single stop covers a lot of ground. You can grab a sandwich, pick up flour, and browse home decor without moving the car.

Prices for furniture are not listed here, so it is best to ask in person. Selection may change over time as pieces sell.

Even if nothing goes home with you, the browse is a pleasant break from the highway.

Items You Did Not Know Existed

Items You Did Not Know Existed
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Part of the fun is the hunt. Many shoppers find products here they had never seen before.

The store carries an assortment of sundries and household items tied to a simpler way of living. These sit alongside grains, flours, and pantry goods.

Some shoppers appreciate the cleaner ingredient lists on certain products. That makes the store popular with people looking for an alternative to mainstream retail.

Not everyone finds it wildly different, though. Some who visit many Amish stores feel the selection is similar to others they have seen.

The store is small. You can walk the grocery section quickly, so it is a manageable stop rather than an all day adventure.

That compact size has an upside for road trippers. You can browse, shop, and be back on the highway without losing your afternoon.

Keep an open mind and take a slow lap. The best discovery might be hiding on a bottom shelf.

Atmosphere and Who Feels at Home

Atmosphere and Who Feels at Home
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Clean floors and friendly faces leave a lasting impression. The store is often described as tidy, with staff who are helpful and kind.

The crowd is a mix. Locals stock up on supplies, while travelers heading to and from places like Traverse City and Grand Rapids stop for lunch.

The store has changed ownership, and some longtime regulars have noticed differences. Prices have risen, and wait times at the deli and register may be longer than before.

Families with small children should know the aisles can feel tight. Pushing a cart around displays and end caps can be tricky when other shoppers are present.

A small umbrella stroller works better than a wide double stroller. The floor is continuous cement, though some spots may be narrow for wheelchairs.

Retirees on a scenic drive and families grabbing a quick bite will both find it easy to navigate. Just go in expecting a small, busy country store rather than a supermarket.

A little patience goes a long way here.

Leave the Plastic at Home

Leave the Plastic at Home
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Here is the single most important tip in this entire article. Bring cash.

The store does not accept credit or debit cards. Payment is cash or check only.

Plenty of first timers learn this the hard way at the register. It is mentioned so often that it has become something of a rite of passage.

Plan ahead before you exit the highway. A quick stop at an ATM earlier in the trip can save a lot of hassle.

Think about how much you might spend. A sandwich, a pack of cookies, and a few bulk items can add up faster than expected.

If you plan to browse the furniture side, bring a checkbook or extra cash in case something catches your eye. Larger purchases are not something you want to miss over a payment issue.

The cash only policy fits the old fashioned charm of the place. Consider it part of the experience, and your wallet will be ready.

Hours, Days, and Timing Your Stop

Hours, Days, and Timing Your Stop
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Timing is everything with a country store. The hours are simple but come with a twist.

The store is open Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. It is closed on Thursday and Sunday.

That Thursday closure catches some people off guard. Check your route before planning a midweek stop.

Arriving earlier in the day may give you the best bakery selection. Popular items can sell out, especially on busy days.

Tuesday is the day to aim for if hand pies are on your list. Saturdays tend to bring weekend travelers, so expect lines.

The store sits close to M-115, which links up with routes between Grand Rapids and Traverse City. It works well as a lunch stop on a northbound or southbound drive.

Since hours can change, it is wise to confirm before heading out. The store website is a good place to start, and a little planning makes for a smooth visit.

Worth the Detour for Michiganders

Worth the Detour for Michiganders
© Yoder’s of Tustin Bulk Foods, Deli, Bakery, Furniture, Tustin, MI

Not every roadside stop deserves a spot in your travel plans. This one makes a strong case.

A fresh sandwich on homemade bread, a pack of buttery raisin cookies, and a few bulk staples make for a satisfying, affordable stop. Add the furniture side, and there is something for nearly everyone.

It is not a giant store, and some prices run higher than chain grocers. The charm comes from the homemade food and the simple country setting.

For Michigan families driving north for the weekend, it is an easy lunch break. Retirees exploring small towns will find it fits right into a relaxed day trip.

Bring cash, check the hours, and arrive hungry. Those three steps cover most of what you need to know.

Tustin may be a small dot on the map, but this store gives drivers a good reason to take the exit. Your next trip up M-115 could use a sandwich stop, and this might just be the one you talk about all the way home.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *