The 9 Best Bagels in Miami That Are Totally Worth the Carb Splurge

Miami might be known for Cuban sandwiches and stone crabs, but the bagel scene is quietly booming across the city. From traditional water-boiled classics to innovative flavors with a Miami twist, these doughy delights have found their place in the 305’s culinary landscape. Whether you’re team schmear or sandwich, these nine bagel spots offer carb-loaded goodness that’s worth every delicious bite.

1. Bagel Club Miami

Family-owned since 1994, Bagel Club Miami has perfected their recipe through decades of dough-making expertise. Their bagels strike that magical balance – crackling exterior with a chewy, tender inside that pulls apart in satisfying stretchy ribbons.

Locals swear by their everything bagel topped with nova lox, but don’t sleep on their jalapeño cheddar variety paired with scallion cream cheese. The shop maintains that authentic New York-style boiling method before baking.

Weekend mornings bring lines out the door, but the wait becomes part of the experience as regulars chat while eyeing the rotating bagel baskets behind the counter. Their coffee is surprisingly excellent too!

2. Fiore Caffe Miami

Hidden gem alert! Fiore Caffe might be better known for its Italian pastries, but their small-batch bagels have developed a cult following among Miami foodies. The owner trained in Montreal, bringing that distinctive honey-water boiling technique south to Miami.

Unlike denser New York-style offerings, these bagels feature a slightly sweeter dough with a more delicate crumb. Their rosemary sea salt bagel paired with house-made veggie cream cheese creates flavor magic in your mouth.

The café’s charming courtyard setting makes bagel enjoyment even more delightful. Pro tip: they sell out by noon most days, so morning visits are essential for scoring these limited-quantity treasures.

3. Zak the Baker

Wynwood’s beloved bakery isn’t just about sourdough – Zak Stern’s bagels deserve their own spotlight. Made with organic flour and naturally fermented, these bagels showcase the care and craftsmanship that made Zak famous throughout Miami’s food scene.

The sesame bagel stands out with its generous seed coating that adds nutty flavor and delightful crunch. Pair it with their house-smoked fish spread for a truly transcendent experience.

While not traditional in the strictest sense, these bagels reflect Zak’s commitment to quality ingredients and artisanal methods. The industrial-chic setting adds to the experience, making that inevitable weekend wait worthwhile for bagel enthusiasts.

4. Toasted Bagelry & Deli

Morning warriors flock to Toasted Bagelry & Deli for their consistent quality and generous portions. The bagels here strike that perfect textural balance – substantial without being too dense, with a properly chewy interior that bagel purists demand.

Their cinnamon raisin bagel deserves special mention, packed with plump fruit and just the right spice level. For savory fans, the spinach bagel with egg and cheese makes breakfast dreams come true.

With multiple locations across Miami, Toasted has mastered the neighborhood bagel shop vibe while maintaining quality across stores. The staff remembers regulars’ orders, adding that community touch that keeps customers coming back morning after morning.

5. Coral Bagels

Old-school charm defines Coral Bagels, a neighborhood institution serving authentic New York-style bagels since 1985. The no-frills atmosphere lets the food take center stage – exactly as it should be for serious bagel hunters.

Their pumpernickel bagel ranks among Miami’s finest, with a distinctive flavor that pairs beautifully with their homemade whitefish salad. Regulars know to order the “Bagel Wheel” for meetings – an assortment of mini bagels that disappear alarmingly fast.

The deli counter offers classic Jewish specialties alongside their bagel selection. Early birds catch the freshest batch, still warm from the oven, around 7 AM. Cash-only policy adds to the throwback vibe that makes this spot feel like a portal to Brooklyn.

6. El Bagel

From food truck sensation to brick-and-mortar hotspot, El Bagel has revolutionized Miami’s bagel game with their sourdough-based creations. The tangy undertones and perfect crust development create bagels worth the inevitable weekend lines.

Their signature “King Guava” sandwich combines cream cheese, guava marmalade, and potato sticks for a Miami-meets-Jewish-deli mashup that somehow works brilliantly. The bagels themselves feature that coveted mahogany exterior with properly developed gluten structure inside.

Started by a Miami native who missed good bagels, this spot maintains strict production limits to ensure quality. They’ve been known to sell out by mid-morning, especially on weekends. The colorful, Instagram-worthy space matches the creative energy of their menu.

7. Outrageous Bagel Co.

Rainbow bagels and unconventional flavors might seem gimmicky, but Outrageous Bagel Co. backs up their creative approach with seriously good technique. Their French toast bagel, topped with maple cream chees,e has converted even traditional bagel purists.

Beyond the Instagram-worthy colors, these bagels deliver on texture – properly boiled before baking for that characteristic chew. The birthday cake bagel might raise eyebrows, but paired with their vanilla bean schmear, it makes for a surprisingly delightful treat.

Founded by two former pastry chefs, this newer addition to Miami’s bagel scene brings playfulness without sacrificing quality. Their small-batch approach means flavors rotate regularly, giving regulars reason to check their social media for weekly specials.

8. Toasted Bagelry & Deli

The Brickell location of this popular mini-chain deserves its own mention for consistently excellent bagels that fuel downtown Miami’s workday warriors. Their everything bagel achieves the perfect seed-to-dough ratio that many competitors miss.

Business meetings happen over their loaded bagel sandwiches, with the “Hangover Helper” (egg, cheese, bacon and avocado) being particularly popular among the post-happy-hour crowd. Unlike some bagel spots that peak at breakfast, Toasted Brickell maintains quality through lunch.

The open kitchen lets you watch bagel magic happen while waiting in the (fast-moving) line. Their house-made flavored cream cheeses, particularly the jalapeño, elevate already excellent bagels to must-have status for downtown dwellers and workers.

9. Bagel Boss Miami Beach

Beach vibes meet bagel tradition at this Ocean Drive spot where New York-style bagels get a South Beach makeover. Hand-rolled and boiled daily, these bagels maintain authentic technique while embracing Miami’s colorful personality.

Their salt bagel deserves special praise – perfectly crusted with large crystal salt that creates a flavor explosion against the chewy interior. Pair it with their house-cured lox for a breakfast that rivals anything in Manhattan.

Morning beach walks end deliciously here, where outdoor seating lets you people-watch while enjoying your carb-laden treasure. Despite the tourist-heavy location, locals brave the seasonal crowds for these exceptional bagels. The Cuban coffee options alongside traditional bagels represent Miami’s melting pot perfectly.