9 Must-Try Toledo Pizza Spots That Have Locals Hooked

Toledo knows good pizza. From family-owned neighborhood joints to innovative pizza pioneers, this Ohio city serves up some seriously delicious pies that keep locals coming back for more. Whether you’re craving traditional deep dish, wood-fired perfection, or unique specialty toppings, these nine pizza spots represent the best of what Toledo has to offer.

1. The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar

Family recipes meet modern flair at this beloved local hangout. The hand-tossed dough creates the perfect foundation for their signature crispy-yet-chewy crust that regulars rave about. Weekend evenings bring crowds of loyal customers waiting for a taste of their famous Detroit-style square pizzas topped with Wisconsin brick cheese that caramelizes beautifully along the edges.

The relaxed atmosphere and craft beer selection make it easy to see why Toledo pizza lovers stubbornly refuse to go anywhere else.

2. PizzaPapalis

Chicago-style deep dish heaven exists right in downtown Toledo. Each mammoth creation requires nearly 40 minutes to prepare properly – a wait that locals know is absolutely worth it. The layers tell the story: flaky butter crust, mountains of cheese, fresh ingredients, and that signature chunky tomato sauce on top rather than underneath.

First-timers often gasp when their server delivers the knife-and-fork affair that more closely resembles a savory pie than traditional pizza. The Spinach & Feta specialty pizza has converted even the most dedicated meat lovers.

3. Home Slice Pizza

Tucked away in a cozy corner of Toledo’s Old West End, Home Slice captures New York-style pizza perfection. Their giant, foldable slices have the ideal balance of thin, crispy crust and just enough chew to satisfy any pizza purist. The owner learned his craft in Brooklyn before bringing authentic techniques to Ohio.

Locals appreciate the simplicity – quality ingredients without unnecessary frills. The margherita pizza showcases this philosophy perfectly with fresh mozzarella, basil, and a light, flavorful sauce that lets each element shine.

4. Pizza Cat

Weird and wonderful creations make this funky spot a standout in Toledo’s pizza scene. Where else can you find mac-and-cheese pizza alongside pies topped with BBQ pulled pork or buffalo chicken? The late-night hours attract college students and night owls seeking something beyond ordinary pizza options. Their delivery drivers, known for lightning-fast service, have become local celebrities in their bright, cat-themed vehicles.

The restaurant’s commitment to quality ingredients, despite their quirky combination,s keeps customers purring with satisfaction.

5. Zaza Wood Fired Pizza & Mediterranean Cuisine

Authenticity reigns supreme at this Mediterranean-inspired treasure. The centerpiece wood-fired oven, imported from Italy, reaches scorching temperatures to create perfectly blistered crusts in just 90 seconds. Owner Zaki personally selects ingredients, including imported olive oils and specialty cheeses that elevate each creation.

The Mediterranean pizza, topped with lamb, feta, and fresh herbs, transports diners straight to the shores of Greece. Locals appreciate the open kitchen design where they can watch pizza-making become performance art.

6. Jo-Jo’s Original Pizzeria

Time seems to stand still at this Toledo institution that’s been family-owned since 1962. The recipes haven’t changed in decades, and loyal customers wouldn’t have it any other way. The signature thin crust has a distinctive cracker-like snap that pairs perfectly with their slightly sweet sauce. Old-school arcade games line the walls while checkered tablecloths complete the nostalgic vibe.

Multiple generations of Toledo families celebrate special occasions here, creating new memories while honoring the tradition of this beloved pizzeria.

7. Amie’s Pizza Factory

Small batch excellence defines this hidden gem on Toledo’s east side. The dough, made fresh daily and allowed to cold-ferment for 72 hours, develops complex flavors that chain pizzerias simply can’t match. Regulars swear by the specialty Buffalo Chicken Ranch pizza, which strikes the perfect balance between spicy and creamy.

The tiny dining area only seats 20, creating an intimate atmosphere where the staff remembers regular customers by name and order. Many locals consider this spot their best-kept secret, though the growing weekend lines suggest the word is getting out.

8. Original Gino’s Pizza

Late-night pizza cravings find their perfect match at this Toledo staple. When most restaurants have closed their doors, Gino’s keeps the ovens hot and the pizzas coming until 3am on weekends. The sauce recipe, a closely guarded family secret for generations, has a distinctive tangy sweetness that locals instantly recognize.

College students appreciate the budget-friendly prices and generous portion sizes. The garlic-butter breadsticks alone inspire devoted followers who sometimes skip the pizza entirely just to enjoy these legendary sides.

9. Mazzas Stone Baked Pizza Co.

Artisanal approach meets neighborhood friendliness at this family-owned gem. The stone deck ovens create a distinctive crisp bottom crust while maintaining a pillowy interior that showcases their 24-hour proofed dough. Seasonal specials feature locally sourced ingredients from Northwest Ohio farms and markets. The Harvest Pizza, available only in autumn, combines butternut squash, caramelized onions, and sage brown butter for a sophisticated flavor profile.

Children love watching their pizzas being made through the open kitchen concept while parents appreciate the thoughtfully curated local beer and wine selection.