South Dakota’s 8 Must-Try Burgers—Ranked by Mouthwatering Taste

South Dakota might be known for Mount Rushmore, but locals know its real treasure lies between two buns. From small-town diners to biker bars, the Mount Rushmore State serves up some seriously impressive burgers that deserve national attention.

Ready your appetite as we explore the eight most delicious burger joints that make South Dakota a hidden paradise for burger lovers.

1. Black Hills Burger & Pizza Co. — Custer

Black Hills Burger & Pizza Co. in Custer is a must-visit for burger lovers seeking bold, handcrafted flavors in South Dakota. Known for using fresh, locally sourced ingredients, their signature burgers deliver juicy, perfectly seasoned patties with creative toppings that set them apart.

The Hot Granny, featuring applewood bacon, cream cheese, and jalapeños, is a crowd favorite that perfectly balances smoky, creamy, and spicy flavors. This cozy spot offers a true taste of the Black Hills with every bite.

2. JL Beers — Sioux Falls

JL Beers in Sioux Falls is a local favorite known for its inventive burgers and extensive beer selection. Their menu features crowd-pleasers like the Humpty Dumpty® Burger topped with a fried egg and cheese, and the JL Burger® with grilled onions, cheese, and special sauce. For spice lovers, the Rajun Cajun Burger packs a flavorful punch, while vegetarians can enjoy the Walnut Burger made with walnuts and herbs.

Alongside burgers, JL Beers offers loaded fries, seasoned pretzels, and more. With a casual vibe and friendly service, it’s the perfect spot for delicious burgers paired with great brews.

3. Lewie’s Burgers & Brews — Lead

Lewie’s Burgers & Brews in Lead, South Dakota, is a must-visit for burger lovers craving hearty, half-pound patties in a welcoming, nostalgic setting. Known for creative options like the Southwest Dakota and Mushroom Swiss burgers, Lewie’s combines bold flavors with a fun, casual atmosphere. The interior, filled with unique memorabilia, adds to the charm, making it feel like a local treasure.

With a full bar and arcade games, plus its close location to outdoor attractions like Mickelson Trail and Terry Peak, Lewie’s is a top pick for both travelers and locals seeking a satisfying meal.

4. Nick’s Hamburger Shop — Brookings

Nick’s Hamburger Shop in Brookings, South Dakota, is a cherished local gem serving classic, handcrafted burgers since 1929. Famous for its fresh, never-frozen beef patties and homemade buns made from a secret family recipe, Nick’s delivers simple yet delicious burgers that have stood the test of time. The cozy, nostalgic diner atmosphere keeps customers coming back for generations.

Beyond burgers, their homemade pies add a perfect sweet finish to any meal. Recognized on the National Register of Historic Places, Nick’s is more than just a restaurant—it’s a beloved South Dakota tradition and a must-stop for any burger enthusiast.

5. The Knuckle Saloon — Sturgis

The Knuckle Saloon in Sturgis, South Dakota, is more than just a biker bar—it’s a vibrant hub of local culture and history. Known for its impressive collection of motorcycle memorabilia, it offers a one-of-a-kind atmosphere that draws enthusiasts and visitors alike. The menu features hearty favorites like the Rodeo Burger and Buffalo Burger, alongside award-winning craft beers such as the Knucklehead Red.

Open daily with live music and events, especially during the famous Sturgis Motorcycle Rally, The Knuckle Saloon perfectly blends great food, entertainment, and a unique glimpse into the Black Hills’ biker heritage.

6. Murph’s Burgers & Fries — Sioux Falls

Murph’s Burgers & Fries in Sioux Falls started as a food truck before opening a popular brick-and-mortar spot. Founded by Murphy Lundie, this eatery serves up creative burgers like the signature Murph Burger topped with rich bacon jam and the lighter Murphette. They also offer a tasty Beyond Meat option for plant-based eaters. Their loaded fries, customizable with house-made sauces like aioli and barbecue, are a local favorite.

With fresh ingredients and inventive flavors, Murph’s delivers comfort food with a modern twist—making it a must-try for anyone craving delicious, elevated burgers in Sioux Falls.

7. Sickies Garage Burgers & Brews — Rapid City

Sickies Garage Burgers & Brews in Rapid City offers a thrilling burger experience with a menu boasting 50 unique burgers paired with 50 craft beers. From bold creations like the Glazed Doughnut Burger to classic favorites, every bite packs a punch. The lively garage-themed atmosphere adds character, making it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.

With rotating taps featuring both local and national brews, Sickies delivers not just great food but a full sensory experience that keeps fans coming back for more.

8. Sugar Shack — Deadwood

Sugar Shack in Deadwood is a beloved Black Hills eatery known for its hearty burgers and classic breakfast dishes. After rebuilding from a 2023 fire, it reopened with the same comforting menu and added improved accessibility. Favorites include the signature Sugar Burger and the popular Stud Muffin breakfast. With generous portions and a welcoming atmosphere, Sugar Shack serves locals and travelers alike.

Open daily with both indoor and outdoor seating, it remains a must-visit spot for anyone exploring the Deadwood area.