15 Cincinnati Pizzerias That Deserve a Spot on Your Foodie Bucket List

Cincinnati’s pizza scene offers incredible variety that goes far beyond typical chain restaurants. From wood-fired artisan pies to classic neighborhood joints, the Queen City serves up amazing slices that satisfy every craving. Local pizzerias have been perfecting their recipes for decades, creating unique flavors you won’t find anywhere else. Get ready to discover the most delicious pizza destinations that make Cincinnati a true foodie paradise.

1. Chameleon

Hidden in Northside, this colorful spot transforms ordinary ingredients into extraordinary pizza masterpieces. Artists and food lovers gather here for creative combinations that change with the seasons.

Wood-fired ovens create perfectly charred crusts with smoky flavors that complement fresh, locally-sourced toppings. The menu features unique options like duck confit and butternut squash that sound fancy but taste amazing.

Cozy atmosphere makes every visit feel special, whether you’re on a date or hanging with friends. Don’t miss their famous Brussels sprouts pizza that converts even the biggest vegetable skeptics.

2. Werkhaus Pizza and Pasta

Located in trendy Over-the-Rhine, this industrial-chic restaurant serves authentic Italian-style pies with serious attention to detail. Exposed brick walls and modern lighting create the perfect backdrop for date night.

Fresh pasta made daily pairs beautifully with their thin-crust pizzas that feature imported Italian ingredients. The margherita pizza showcases simple perfection with San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella.

Craft cocktails and local beers complement the food menu perfectly. Weekend brunch adds another dimension with breakfast pizzas that combine eggs, bacon, and cheese in unexpected ways.

3. Taglio

Roman-style pizza al taglio brings authentic Italian street food culture to Cincinnati’s downtown scene. Square slices sold by weight let you sample multiple flavors without committing to a whole pie.

Fresh ingredients arrive daily from local farms and specialty importers, ensuring every bite delivers maximum flavor. The crust stays light and airy while supporting generous toppings like prosciutto di Parma and fresh arugula.

Counter service keeps things casual and affordable, making it perfect for lunch breaks or quick dinner solutions. Try the mortadella and pistachio combination that sounds weird but tastes incredible.

4. Adriatico’s

Since 1985, this family-owned gem has been serving thick-crust pizza that defines comfort food in Cincinnati. Generous portions and reasonable prices keep families coming back generation after generation.

Hand-tossed dough rises slowly for 24 hours, creating crusts that are crispy outside and fluffy inside. The sauce recipe remains a closely guarded family secret that balances sweetness and acidity perfectly.

Multiple locations across the city make it easy to satisfy cravings anywhere. Their pepperoni cups curl up when cooked, creating little pools of spicy oil that pizza lovers absolutely adore.

5. Goodfellas Pizzeria

New York-style pizza finds its Cincinnati home in this authentic pizzeria that takes thin crust seriously. Owners from Brooklyn brought their grandmother’s recipes and old-school techniques to the Midwest.

Large, foldable slices with crispy-chewy crusts transport you straight to Little Italy. Fresh mozzarella melts perfectly over tangy tomato sauce that’s seasoned with herbs and garlic.

Late-night hours cater to downtown workers and party-goers looking for quality food after midnight. The white pizza with ricotta, garlic, and spinach offers a delicious alternative to traditional red sauce options.

6. Catch-a-Fire Pizza

Jamaican-inspired flavors meet traditional pizza craftsmanship at this unique Clifton spot near the University of Cincinnati. Jerk chicken and plantains create tropical combinations that surprise and delight adventurous eaters.

College students and professors gather here for affordable meals that pack serious flavor punch. The curry chicken pizza sounds unusual but delivers amazing taste with coconut milk-infused sauce.

Reggae music and bright colors transport diners to the Caribbean while staying rooted in Cincinnati’s diverse food scene. Don’t leave without trying their famous jerk wings that pair perfectly with any pizza choice.

7. A Tavola

Upscale Italian dining meets neighborhood charm in this Hyde Park restaurant that treats pizza as fine art. Chef-driven creations feature seasonal ingredients and house-made charcuterie that elevate casual dining.

Wood-fired ovens reach temperatures over 900 degrees, creating leopard-spotted crusts that bubble and char in all the right places. Fresh pasta dishes complement the pizza menu for those wanting variety.

Wine selection focuses on Italian varietals that pair beautifully with rich, complex flavors. The fig and prosciutto pizza with arugula and balsamic glaze represents sophisticated comfort food at its finest.

8. Ramundo’s Pizzeria

Family recipes from Sicily create authentic flavors that have satisfied Cincinnati families for over three decades. Traditional methods and imported ingredients ensure every pizza tastes like it came straight from Italy.

Hand-stretched dough and slow-simmered sauce form the foundation for generous toppings that never skimp on quality. The Italian sausage gets made fresh daily using spices that have been perfected over generations.

Casual atmosphere welcomes everyone from construction workers to business executives looking for honest, delicious food. Their meatball pizza combines house-made meatballs with ricotta cheese for ultimate comfort food satisfaction.

9. Taft’s Brewpourium

Craft beer and artisan pizza create the perfect pairing at this converted church venue that combines history with modern dining. Soaring ceilings and stained glass windows provide stunning backdrop for casual meals.

House-brewed beers complement wood-fired pizzas that feature creative toppings and perfect crusts. The brewery atmosphere attracts young professionals and beer enthusiasts looking for quality food and drinks.

Live music and special events make every visit feel like a celebration. Try their IPA-braised pork pizza that incorporates their own beer into the cooking process for unique flavor combinations.

10. Dewey’s Pizza

Born in Cincinnati, this local chain has expanded across the region while maintaining quality and consistency that locals trust. Gourmet toppings and creative combinations set them apart from typical pizza chains.

Edgar’s White pizza with olive oil, garlic, and three cheeses represents their signature style that focuses on fresh, high-quality ingredients. Salads and appetizers round out the menu for complete dining experiences.

Multiple locations make it convenient for families and groups to enjoy consistently good pizza anywhere in the city. Their green lantern pizza with pesto, chicken, and sun-dried tomatoes offers Mediterranean flavors with local appeal.

11. Forno Osteria + Bar

Authentic Neapolitan pizza certified by the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana brings true Italian tradition to Cincinnati’s dining scene. Imported Italian flour and San Marzano tomatoes ensure authenticity in every bite.

Ninety-second cooking times in 900-degree ovens create pizzas with soft, pillowy crusts and perfectly melted fresh mozzarella. The simple margherita showcases technique and ingredient quality over flashy toppings.

Elegant atmosphere suits special occasions while remaining welcoming for casual dinners. Wine selection features Italian varietals chosen specifically to complement the Neapolitan pizza experience and transport diners to southern Italy.

12. Mio’s Pizzeria

Neighborhood institution serves classic American-style pizza that hits all the right comfort food notes without any pretension. Generous cheese coverage and perfectly seasoned sauce create the pizza memories childhood dreams are made of.

Family-friendly atmosphere welcomes everyone from little league teams to grandparents celebrating birthdays. The pepperoni pizza delivers exactly what you expect – crispy edges, gooey cheese, and satisfying flavors.

Reasonable prices and large portions make it perfect for feeding hungry families without breaking the budget. Their deluxe combination pizza loads on the toppings for those who want everything on their slice.

13. Fireside Pizza

Cozy neighborhood spot creates the perfect atmosphere for intimate dinners and casual gatherings with friends. Brick ovens and warm lighting make every visit feel like coming home to good food and comfortable surroundings.

Hand-tossed crusts strike the perfect balance between New York thin and Chicago thick, creating versatile bases for both simple and complex topping combinations. Fresh vegetables and quality meats ensure every ingredient contributes meaningfully.

Local following includes regulars who consider this their go-to pizza destination for consistent quality and friendly service. The meat lovers pizza satisfies carnivorous cravings with generous portions of pepperoni, sausage, and bacon.

14. MOD Pizza

Build-your-own pizza concept lets creativity run wild with unlimited toppings for one fixed price. Assembly line format moves quickly while accommodating dietary restrictions and personal preferences with ease.

Artisan-style thin crusts cook in under five minutes, making it perfect for lunch breaks and quick family dinners. Gluten-free and vegan options ensure everyone can participate in the pizza-making experience.

Casual, modern atmosphere appeals to younger crowds and busy professionals who want quality food without long waits. The ability to customize every aspect means even the pickiest eaters can create their perfect pizza combination.

15. Trotta’s Pizza & Drive Thru

Unique drive-through pizza service brings convenience to quality food in a way few other places can match. Hot, fresh pizza ready for pickup means busy families can enjoy good food without leaving their cars.

Traditional recipes and cooking methods ensure drive-through convenience doesn’t compromise on taste or quality. The pepperoni and cheese combination delivers classic flavors that satisfy without any fancy additions needed.

Local institution has been serving the community for decades, proving that sometimes the best innovations are also the simplest ones. Perfect for rainy days, busy schedules, or when you just want good pizza without the fuss.